Just popped my head into the forum after a break from the madness, and there has been some sort of temporary resolution on this thread, theres still no useful consensus for the long term in my opinion though.
My main gripes with the esoteric takeover we've seen (people have already mentioned some, but I'll include them anyway) :
Esoteric comments have blemished certain subjects that *require* a scientific approach - when talking about drugs / chemistry, misinformation can kill.
Any questions asked about the topics receive incoherent answers, and there is a general unwillingness to help others understand where their position comes from.
People taking criticism personally - we're all adults here (most of us anyway), so instead of getting upset, try to look at whats *really* being said - the substance of the criticism, and address it, if no substance can be found - say so: ie. "what's your point".
For those that say "just ignore it", an analogy: If you saw a friend or family member being converted to something which you had good reason to believe is BS (eg. scientology), you'd want to help give them the information they need to make an informed opinion.
This analogy works on many different levels - there are people on this forum who are in danger of taking esoterics seriously, without being properly informed about the logical pitfalls inherent in it.
On another level I'm talking about the forum in general - as a "functioning" community I think there is a balance required between belief and knowledge - both are good things in my opinion, but people need to be respectful of the limits of each. I think that the limits of belief have been overstepped far to often recently.
Forum members have been alienated by aggressive proseltysing of belief. I assume I'm not the only one that feels this way? This only serves to further imbalance the scope of opinion here.
Are we agreed that this alienation is happening? Are we agreed that something must be done about it?
I would like my mind put at ease about the things I've mentioned - either an explanation of why my points are invalid, why the behaviour is acceptable, or assurance that it will be kept in check / something is being done about it.
This is mainly aimed at aha..thingmy (I'll call you charley from now on if you don't mind), but could well apply to myself and others - I admit I have been a bit vitriolic with my language concerning esoterics in a reactionary sense, but if there is an effort on the part of others to address the issues I've raised, I shouldn't be so harsh (and if I am you can tell me off!
).
Please consider and comment on what I've said - either address the points I've made, or suggest another psychedelics forum I might be interested in.