IJesusChrist
Holofractale de l'hypervérité
- Inscrit
- 22/7/08
- Messages
- 7 482
restin a dit:So the job of psychiatrist should be given to schizos and suiciders? Fine. A doc that makes a heart OP doesn't need having had one as well, a judge that judges a murderer doesn't need to commit a crime. Do you think noone was helped with a psychiatrist? WRONG. If a person dies on the bed of a surgeon, shall we eliminate medicine?I just don't see how a man or woman who has been relatively sober their entire life can help with a person of schizophrenia. That's like having a guide for mt.everest who has never left his house.
Your comparing the mind to the heart?
The mind can make 1x10^(million) connections... Each one is a memory, or a feeling, or a bit of information or more.
You cannot compare psycho-psychiatry with heart surgery, those guys have it easy, they know how the heart works.
A neurologist comes in with medicine, and the psychologist comes in with books.
The medicine sometimes works, and the books sometimes work, until you get to schizophrenia, in which case they tranqualize you, and give up essentially.
Sure there are a few people out there that do help - rarely. But still, do you believe the ones that actually do help have never been there?
A sober psychologist will NOT help with schizophrenia.