BrainEater a dit:
Mara a dit:
For me there is no God that judges people, to send them to heaven or hell, God does not have opinions, God does not prefer a certain kind of food on his altar, or a certain prayer, or a religion, and God does not make virgins pregnant.
so how could maria give birth to jesus if she was a virgin?????????? :weedman:
Mary would have been roughly 13 when she gave birth. It's not the done thing for unmarried 13 year olds to have children unmarried. That likely results in death. Even today in some countries.
Would a 13 year old say God had sex with them to avoid being stoned to death? I think a thirteen year old would say anything.
There is no proof that Mary was a virgin, only that she said she was.The bible isn't proof - it recounts what she said.
Also, if Jesus was born in December, why were shepherds out?
My main gripe with Theistic religions is the atrocities they will commit to make everyone else believe how LOVING their God is. Yes, yes, they aren't all like that blah blah. Look to history and all the RELIGIOUS CONFLICTS.
God used to send plagues, part the red sea - now, nothing. Why?
Did he care more about people in the past? Not likely. What's more likely that if he does exist (don't get too wound up on "he") he wouldn't interfere.
The problem with the RELIGIOUS God is most things are arbitrary.
Jesus needed to die for our sins so that people could go to heaven. Does anyone truly believe that God could have absolute power and STILL need to create a child on a small rock in the middle of nowhere JUST so that child could die a HORRIBLY PAINFUL death so that he could invite people INTO HIS OWN HOUSE.
My friends visit me all the time, I've never needed to sacrifice my first born.
It's just silly!
If God knew everything, he would have knew BEFORE HE CREATED ADAM AND EVE that they would SIN. Therefor, he may have well have created them TO sin. They couldn't not Sin, God knew they would Sin before he created them. Why would he create them, knowing it was 100%, inescapable that they would do something he didn't want them to(he told them not to, they did, but he would have knew that anyway) and then punish them for it?!
In fact, before I was born, God would have complete, 100% knowledge of my every thought and action - if God then, seeing those actions allowed me to be born - and I did something "bad" or "evil" like... I don't know... became an axe murderer, God must have saw that coming. It's God's fault. Christians would send ME to hell for God's mistake?
In the past when I say something along these lines people say "You have free will". I say - unless God has IMPERFECT KNOWLEDGE than my freewill can ONLY do exactly what he already KNOWS I will do and HAS KNOWN FOREVER even BEFORE he created the PLANET. That means GOD CREATED THE PLANET KNOWING I WOULD MURDER PEOPLE WITH AN AXE.
I had no choice in the matter, from the first moment when God created time EVERYTHING would just be following a path that was PLANNED by God (because God could have created the world with Islands in different places, etc, and he would have full knowledge of what people would be doing *now* based on the configurations he chose) meaning that NOTHING ANYONE COULD EVER DO deserves ANY KIND OF PUNISHMENT, meaning that if Christians ARE right and Hell DOES EXIST, then God is nothing short of a .
I think that pretty much gets rid of any religion with a God and a punishment if you do things wrong - everyone would just be acting out God's plan - why would a SANE and LOVING and JUST God punish MILLIONS and MILLIONS of people for following a path that he put them on?
So, what is left?